“Hellboy” (2019) is a reboot that attempts to bring a darker and more mature take on Mike Mignola’s iconic character. Starring David Harbour as Hellboy, the film introduces a new storyline involving the ancient sorceress Nimue, played by Milla Jovovich.
One of the film’s primary challenges lies in the comparisons with Guillermo del Toro’s earlier adaptations, which garnered a dedicated fanbase. While David Harbour brings a different energy to the character, the inevitable comparisons with Ron Perlman’s portrayal make it a divisive aspect.
The narrative, centered around the battle against Nimue and the impending apocalypse, suffers from uneven pacing. Some scenes feel rushed, while others linger, affecting the overall flow of the story. The attempt to blend horror, humor, and action also leads to tonal inconsistencies, with moments of levity undercutting the darker elements.
Visual effects became a major point of criticism, as CGI-heavy sequences were deemed unconvincing. However, practical effects were praised for their creativity and execution.
Despite its flaws, the film has its merits. David Harbour’s performance, while divisive, has its supporters, and the supporting cast delivers solid portrayals. The decision to explore a more graphic and R-rated approach appealed to some viewers who appreciated the film’s attempt to delve into darker themes.
In summary, “Hellboy” (2019) struggled to live up to the expectations set by its predecessors. While it had moments of creativity and potential, the film faced challenges in maintaining a cohesive tone, pacing issues, and the inevitable comparisons to the beloved earlier adaptations. The result was a mixed reception from both critics and audiences, leaving the reboot with an uphill battle to establish its own identity within the “Hellboy” franchise.